Login Profile
Get News Updates
For local news delivered via email enter address here:
Real Estate Automotive Employment Services
    Classifieds Marketplace
      Media Kit Forms
      News
      HOME
      Front Page
      GMN Photo Galleries
      Bulletin Board
      Letters
      Obituaries
      Sports
      Online Obituary Submission
      Featured Special Sections
      Health & Fitness Guide
      About Us
      Archive
      Contact Us
      Services
      Advertiser Index
      Copyright
      2000 - 2009 GMN All Rights Reserved
      Terms of Use & Privacy
      Editorials April 3, 2008  RSS feed

      Knowledge of one's origins is a basic birthright

      Guest Column
      PEGGI STURMFELS

      New Jersey State legislators are considering legislation to restore to over 150,000 citizens their right to know who they are.

      As these deliberations take place, I would ask that they take a moment to see a moment (or many moments) of my life.

      Sometimes it is a seemingly benign comment. At a lively discussion with a group of friends, one member decries what the "bastards" did. While others laughed, I cringed a little. Bastard was the offensive word, and bastard is what I am.

      I have lived for over half a century in a world that defines me as less than, or must prove myself as worthy of personage as my friends, my neighbors, strangers and my family. Our culture diminishes adopted children in many subtle ways that most folks don't even think about. In words and laws, adoptees have been thrown into a caste system that encourages secrecy and shame.

      And somehow we have allowed the children who have had no say in the causative circumstance or the behavior to be the bearers of that secrecy and shame. For centuries, bastard children could not inherit from their biological parent, unless that parent acknowledged them. That acknowledgement often happened by adoption. Then and even today, adopted children have to be specifically acknowledged in some wills.

      The news media is quick to point out that a suspect or criminal who is adopted is outed as such. Perhaps they feel that being adopted somehow explains bad behavior. Orphans are thought of as poor souls, conjuring up images of Oliver Twist, malnourished children and rat- infested living quarters. Adoption became a way of rescuing them. But with the rescue, we often put upon them the burden of showing that they are worthy of that effort.

      We feel that they should be grateful for the chance of being adopted.And we question the appropriateness of their behavior should they ask the questions that all people have a birthright of knowing the answers to.

      Whiney you say? OK, let's start there. Have you sat with your kids, looking through the family album or old pictures, telling them the stories of their history? The stories passed down through generations that completes their legacy and gives them a past to build their future? Well, I've got that too. But the nagging truth is that mine is borrowed.

      So who am I really? The agency said I was the shame of a one-night stand. I preferred my version of the love child of two people torn apart by circumstance and time. Newfound family members share different facts that bear no resemblance to the ones my (adoptive) parents were told. So still after all these years, I begin and end with me.

      Critics of these bills talk about a presumed pact made with birth mothers to protect them from any public scrutiny. But who protected the children from public ridicule? Who went and stood beside the children in the schoolyards as kids taunted them, telling them that something was so horrible about them that their own mothers didn't want them?Who benefited from the incomplete grade received on the seventh-grade science project requiring students to trace their family tree? Who thought about the feelings of a youngster during the eighthgrade English class discussion of the play

      The Bad Seed?

      What pact held these kids in their arms at family reunion gatherings that made them outsiders? What regulation explained away the fear and hurt of hearing your cousins being referred to as the "real grandchildren" by your grandmother? What document gave comfort or support every time a doctor asked about family medical history and the answer is always " I don't know"? And who was served when polite people and the state decided that bastards were to be labeled illegitimate?

      Protecting the privacy of one family so often abused the everyday living of the child given away, and their family too. Tell me what day you were born?Me? On or about Dec. 10. No one is sure. Tell me what ethnic background you claim? Me? I've been told either Irish or Scottish, maybe some English. Recently, I might be Swedish. When did you take your first step? What were your first words? Where did you spend the first three years of your life? Whose eyes do you have? Whose smile? Nose? Me? Again - nothing.

      One of my quirky little "adoption" phobias? I refused to date anyone with red hair, because I was afraid that he might be my brother. How was your parents' health? Did they have arthritis, strokes, breast cancer, Alzheimer's, etc.? And your children- who do they look like? Do they have a heart condition? Hearing loss? Kidney disease? Allergies and asthma? And their children - a new generation now faced with having to have genetic testing, because there are no answers to basic questions.

      My decades-long search for answers has revealed half-sisters and brothers, cousins, aunts and uncles and stories that didn't match the agency's "unidentifying" information. But only possibly because, absent my birth certificate, there is no verification and no certainty that I belong to these people.

      Let me say one more thing about this need to protect the birth mothers, or the adoptive mothers from this horrible secret pain (their child) that they have had to endure. As a mother, both biological and adoptive, it is my obligation to do everything I can to ensure the emotional health of my child. When my daughter needed to find answers, my husband and I did whatever was needed to help her make that journey, even though we were frightened by what she might find.

      Passage of open records for adoptees will restore to hundreds of adoptees in New Jersey and their families the basic human right to know who they are. It's what you've known all along. Why can't we?

      Peggi Sturmfels

      Program Organizer New Jersey Environmental

      Federation

      Belmar